Go to main content
J.P. Licks - Newbury St.

J.P. Licks - Newbury St.

173 Newbury Street, Boston, MA 02116
(857) 449-0334
Already Registered? Sign In
Back
J.P. Licks - Newbury St.

Categories

  • Empty Category

Welcome!

Select a category on the left to start your order.

In Stock Cakes

Our cakes are perfect for your party or just to celebrate a great day. They are hand packed with love - not machine-made.

Do you need a cake today? Choose from our "In Stock" selection. Any cake may be inscribed with your special message, and will be ready to pick up in 2 hours at any of our locations.

These cakes are pre-made, and no changes are possible. Please note that once personalized with an inscription, refunds are not possible.

Baby serves 6-8 Medium serves 8-12 Large serves 12-18 Sheet serves 40-50

  • 35.50 - 57.50
    35.50 - 57.50

    Cookies 'n' Cream

    35.50 - 57.50
    Two layers of Cookies ‘n’ Cream ice cream with homemade fudge nestled in the center. Sides are wrapped in crushed Oreo®, and Oreo® halves top the cake.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 35.50
    35.50

    CnC/Vanilla Yogurt Baby

    35.50
    One layer of Cookies ‘n’ Cream yogurt and one layer of vanilla yogurt with homemade fudge nestled in the center. Sides are wrapped in crushed Oreo®, and Oreo® halves top the cake.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 35.50
    35.50

    Chocolate Chip Baby (GF)

    35.50
    Two layers of chocolate chip ice cream with homemade fudge nestled in the center. The sides of the cake are wrapped in chocolate sprinkles. (Gluten Free)
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 41.50
    41.50

    Chocolate Covered Baby

    41.50
    Two layers of rich Cookies ‘n’ Cream ice cream with homemade fudge nestled in the center. The whole cake is enveloped in creamy chocolate ganache and finished with pirouline cookies and chocolate shavings. The ultimate chocolate experience.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 47.00
    47.00

    Coffee Cookies 'n' Cream Medium

    47.00
    Two layers of our creamy Coffee Cookies ‘n’ Cream ice cream with homemade fudge nestled in the center. We frost the cake with our coffee whip topping and top with Oreo® cookies and fudge. Yumm!
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 47.00
    47.00

    Cake Batter Cookies 'n' Cream Medium

    47.00
    Two layers of our Cookies ‘n’ Cake Batter ice cream with a center of rainbow sprinkles, and the sides are enveloped in rainbow sprinkles.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 47.00
    47.00

    MooLala Medium (GF)

    47.00
    One layer of Vanilla and one layer of Chocolate ice cream with homemade fudge between. Decorated with J.P. Licks themed sprinkles and hot pink frosting! (Gluten Free)
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 24.00
    24.00

    Tiramisu Cake

    24.00
    Incredible Tiramisu ice cream stacked between thin layers of moist cake, garnished with fudge and a sprinkle of cocoa. Rave reviews!
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 2.25
    2.25

    Candles

    2.25
    Pack of 24 Birthday Candles
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 3.20
    3.20

    Large Freezer Bag

    3.20
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity

Custom Ice Cream Cakes

All Custom Cakes require 72 hours notice.

Build your own Custom Cake just the way you like it - from the ice cream flavors to the decorations! Ready for pick up in 72 hours at any of our locations. Be inspired and have fun!


* Please note that certain designs (Balloons, Graduation, Ice Cream Cone) only allow for 15 characters inscription *

Please note that these are made to order, therefore refunds are not possible. Please check your order carefully.

Baby serves 6-8 Medium serves 8-12 Large serves 12-18 Sheet serves 40-50

  • 47.40 - 107.90
    47.40 - 107.90

    Custom Chocolate Covered

    47.40 - 107.90
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors, enveloped in creamy chocolate ganache and finished with pirouline cookies and chocolate shavings. The ultimate chocolate experience.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 44.00 - 101.00
    44.00 - 101.00

    Cookies 'n Cream Design

    44.00 - 101.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors. Sides are wrapped in crushed cookies, and Oreo® halves top the cake, finished with whipped topping.
    The color of your cake will change depending on the ice cream flavor you select.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 44.00 - 101.00
    44.00 - 101.00

    Rainbow Sprinkles Design

    44.00 - 101.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors. Sides are wrapped in rainbow sprinkles, with yellow frosting top and bottom.
    This is a gluten free design when GF ice cream flavors are selected.
    The color of your cake will change depending on the ice cream flavor you select.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 44.00 - 101.00
    44.00 - 101.00

    Floral Design

    44.00 - 101.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors. Loads of frosting flowers on top, with pastel confetti-covered sides.
    The color of your cake will change depending on the ice cream flavor you select.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 44.00 - 101.00
    44.00 - 101.00

    Chocolate Sprinkles Design

    44.00 - 101.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors. Sides are wrapped in chocolate sprinkles and top is decorated with frosting.
    This is a gluten free design when GF ice cream flavors are selected.
    The color of your cake will change depending on the ice cream flavor you select.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 44.00 - 101.00
    44.00 - 101.00

    Cow Spot Design

    44.00 - 101.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors. Cake is covered in vanilla ice cream, with chocolate fondant cow spots!
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 44.00 - 101.00
    44.00 - 101.00

    Combed Chocolate Trim Design

    44.00 - 101.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors. Simple combed sides, with chocolate frosting decorations.
    This is a gluten free design when GF ice cream flavors are selected.
    The color of your cake will change depending on the ice cream flavor you select.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 44.00 - 101.00
    44.00 - 101.00

    Heath Bar Design

    44.00 - 101.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors. Crushed Heathbar® covers the sides of the cake.
    The color of your cake will change depending on the ice cream flavor you select.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 44.00 - 101.00
    44.00 - 101.00

    Almond Covered Design

    44.00 - 101.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors. All covered in crushed almonds, and decorated with vanilla frosting.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 44.00 - 101.00
    44.00 - 101.00

    Graduation Design

    44.00 - 101.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors. Graduation-themed design. Please note that there is only room for 15 characters inscription.
    The color of your cake will change depending on the ice cream flavor you select.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 44.00 - 101.00
    44.00 - 101.00

    Balloons Design

    44.00 - 101.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors. Frosting balloons on top, and rainbow sprinkles on the sides.
    This is a gluten free design when GF ice cream flavors are selected.
    The color of your cake will change depending on the ice cream flavor you select.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 44.00 - 101.00
    44.00 - 101.00

    Ice Cream Cone Design

    44.00 - 101.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors. A fun design decorated with a wafer cone. Please note that there is only room for 15 characters inscription.
    Cake picture made with strawberry ice cream. Other flavors will change the color of the cake.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 44.00 - 101.00
    44.00 - 101.00

    Elmo Design

    44.00 - 101.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors. Brighten up that birthday with Elmo!
    The color of your cake will change depending on the ice cream flavor you select.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 25.50
    25.50

    Special Order Pie

    25.50
    Choose one flavor ice cream (including liquor flavors) , a layer of either hot fudge, caramel, or sprinkles, and either a crushed cookie or graham cracker crust.
    The color of your pie will change depending on the ice cream flavor you select.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 2.25
    2.25

    Candles

    2.25
    Pack of 24 Birthday Candles
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 3.20
    3.20

    Large Freezer Bag

    3.20
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity

Custom Cake & Ice Cream Cakes

All Custom Cakes require 72 hours notice.

NEW! Two layers of ice cream with a center of delicious cake!

Now you can have cake with your ice cream!
Choose an exterior design, customize with your two favorite flavors, and choose a vanilla or chocolate cake layer in the middle. Ready for pick up in 72 hours at any of our locations.

Medium size only, serves 8-12.
Cake layer contains gluten.

  • 55.00
    55.00

    Cake & Ice Cream Cookies 'n Cream Design

    55.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors with a center layer of chocolate or vanilla cake. Sides are wrapped in crushed cookies, and Oreo® halves top the cake, finished with whipped topping.
    The color of your cake will change depending on the ice cream flavor you select.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 55.00
    55.00

    Cake & Ice Cream Chocolate Sprinkles Design

    55.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors with a center layer of chocolate or vanilla cake. Sides are wrapped in chocolate sprinkles and top is decorated with frosting.
    The color of your cake will change depending on the ice cream flavor you select.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 55.00
    55.00

    Cake & Ice Cream Rainbow Sprinkles Design

    55.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors with a center layer of chocolate or vanilla cake. Sides are wrapped in rainbow sprinkles, with yellow frosting top and bottom.
    The color of your cake will change depending on the ice cream flavor you select.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 55.00
    55.00

    Cake & Ice Cream Floral Design

    55.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors with a center layer of chocolate or vanilla cake. Loads of frosting flowers on top, with pastel confetti-covered sides.
    The color of your cake will change depending on the ice cream flavor you select.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 55.00
    55.00

    Cake & Ice Cream Cow Spot Design

    55.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors with a center layer of chocolate or vanilla cake. All covered in vanilla ice cream, with chocolate fondant cow spots!
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 55.00
    55.00

    Cake & Ice Cream Combed Chocolate Trim Design

    55.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors with a center layer of chocolate or vanilla cake. Simple combed sides, with chocolate frosting decorations.
    The color of your cake will change depending on the ice cream flavor you select.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 55.00
    55.00

    Cake & Ice Cream Heath Bar Design

    55.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors with a center layer of chocolate or vanilla cake. Crushed Heathbar® covers the sides of the cake.
    The color of your cake will change depending on the ice cream flavor you select.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 55.00
    55.00

    Cake & Ice Cream Almond Covered Design

    55.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors with a center layer of chocolate or vanilla cake. All covered in crushed almonds, and decorated with vanilla frosting.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 55.00
    55.00

    Cake & Ice Cream Graduation Design

    55.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors with a center layer of chocolate or vanilla cake. Graduation-themed design. Please note that there is only room for 15 characters inscription.
    The color of your cake will change depending on the ice cream flavor you select.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 55.00
    55.00

    Cake & Ice Cream Balloons Design

    55.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors with a center layer of chocolate or vanilla cake. Frosting balloons on top, and rainbow sprinkles on the sides.
    The color of your cake will change depending on the ice cream flavor you select.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 55.00
    55.00

    Cake & Ice Cream Cone Design

    55.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors with a center layer of chocolate or vanilla cake. A fun design decorated with a wafer cone. Please note that there is only room for 15 characters inscription.
    Cake picture made with strawberry ice cream. Other flavors will change the color of the cake.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 55.00
    55.00

    Cake & Ice Cream Elmo Design

    55.00
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors with a center layer of chocolate or vanilla cake. Brighten up that birthday with Elmo!
    The color of your cake will change depending on the ice cream flavor you select.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 59.55
    59.55

    Cake & Ice Cream Chocolate Covered

    59.55
    Two layers of your favorite ice cream flavors and a center layer of chocolate or vanilla cake, enveloped in creamy chocolate ganache and finished with pirouline cookies and chocolate shavings. The ultimate chocolate experience.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 2.25
    2.25

    Candles

    2.25
    Pack of 24 Birthday Candles
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 3.20
    3.20

    Large Freezer Bag

    3.20
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity

Sundae Parties, Lixwiches

  • M
    42.00
    42.00

    Make Your Own Sundae Kit

    42.00
    Serves 4.
    Make your own sundaes at home! Choose 1 quart of ice cream, 1 wet topping and 1 dry topping. Included with the kit is whipped cream and cups, spoons and napkins.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 26.25
    26.25

    Lixwich 4-pac

    26.25
    Vanilla ice cream stuffed between two fresh-baked chocolate chunk cookies.
    Package of 4.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 19.25
    19.25

    Cupcakes 5-pac

    19.25
    Choose from chocolate or vanilla, freshly baked in our Jamaica Plain kitchen, with various seasonal decorations. Pack of 5.
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 3.20
    3.20

    Large Freezer Bag

    3.20
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity

Tubs, Quarts, Toppings

  • T
    71.65
    71.65

    Tub Ice Cream

    71.65
    Serves 40
    GF = No Gluten Ingredients
    DF= No Dairy Ingredients
    V= No Animal-derived Ingredients
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 15.45
    15.45

    Quart Ice Cream

    15.45
    Serves up to 5
    GF = No Gluten Ingredients
    DF= No Dairy Ingredients
    V= No Animal-derived Ingredients
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • S
    7.90 - 13.25
    7.90 - 13.25

    Sauce

    7.90 - 13.25
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • T
    4.60 - 13.25
    4.60 - 13.25

    Topping

    4.60 - 13.25
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • S
    3.75 - 14.00
    3.75 - 14.00

    Sugar Cones

    3.75 - 14.00
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • W
    3.75 - 14.00
    3.75 - 14.00

    Wafer Cones

    3.75 - 14.00
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 2.25
    2.25

    Candles

    2.25
    Pack of 24 Birthday Candles
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity
  • 3.20
    3.20

    Large Freezer Bag

    3.20
    For Cakes Only - Click here to to tell us what you want written. Maximum Characters Possible: Baby - 25; Medium & Large - 35
    Quantity

Dynamic Category

      Your Order

      This restaurant is not currently accepting orders.

      Your order is empty.

      {{combo.name}} Delete Combo {{comboPrice(combo)}}

      Already Sent

      Subtotal

      Coupon: {{coupon.name}}
      {{submitButtonText}}

      Info

      Already Registered? Sign In

      Powered by Paytronix Order & Delivery
      {{submitButtonText}}

      Start Your Order

      Sorry, we're closed right now. When do you want to order?

      Order Type
      Order Time
      Sorry, this order can't be completed today. You can still place an order in advance for another day.
      In-store Pick Up Only orders are not available right now.
      We deliver, but delivery is not available right now.

      Already Registered?

      Invalid username or password.
      Forgot password?

      Sign In

      Invalid username or password.
      Forgot password?

      Forgot Your Password?

      Please enter your username, and we'll send you a link to reset your password.

      Please check your e-mail

      Item Added

      Your selection has been added to your order.
      Make Your Order Even Better!

      Item Added

      Your selection has been added to your order.
      Continue Ordering

      Have a Coupon?

      If you have a coupon code, enter it and click Apply Coupon.

      Complete Your Order

      Complete Your Coupon

      You've earned a free item! Select the item you want below.

      Info

      Your Order

      This restaurant is not currently accepting orders.

      Your order is empty.

      {{combo.name}} Delete Combo {{comboPrice(combo)}}

      Already Sent

      Subtotal

      Coupon: {{coupon.name}}
      {{submitButtonText}}

      We're On It!

      Your items have been sent and we're working on it! Want to order more? Go for it!